Windows 11 upgrade and deployment video gets blasted as being 'tone deaf'

Windows 11 Taskbar Icons Surfacepro
Windows 11 Taskbar Icons Surfacepro (Image credit: Daniel Rubino / Windows Central)

What you need to know

  • There has been a lot of discussion, and confusion, around Windows 11 upgrade requirements and policies.
  • Microsoft released a video attempting to clarify matters.
  • The video has not been well received by a portion of viewers.

Update July 27, 2021 at 5:16 p.m. ET: Comments on Microsoft's video have been disabled.

Given that Windows 11 kicked off with widespread confusion over its TPM and hard floor hardware requirements, it was only a matter of time before Microsoft attempted to clarify its stance in response to consumers' queries and complaints about what was, and wasn't, required for Windows 11 upgrading eligibility. However, in attempting to answer consumers frankly, Microsoft seems to have angered a section of them even more.

In its ask-me-anything-themed video entitled "Windows 11 upgrade paths and deployment tools", almost an hour's worth of questions and topics were addressed. However, some viewers felt the answers provided by Microsoft didn't read the room or handle contentious points in a satisfactory manner. The video, as of this post, sits at 3 likes, 63 dislikes, and has a comment section that is (currently) entirely negative and unhappy.

In the video, Microsoft employee Aria states that it "sucks" that some people aren't equipped with eligible devices, but points out how great Windows 11's requirements will be for those who are eligible, when it comes to what those requirements mean for security, productivity, and the overall experience.

"A lot of these answers come off as super tone deaf," the video's top comment reads. "It's looking like Windows 11 will be another Windows 8."

Others in the comments argued that Windows 11's requirements are a thinly veiled ploy to warrant fresh license purchases alongside new machines since free upgrades to existing computers won't earn Microsoft revenue.

Whatever Microsoft's stance is regarding how Windows 11 policies benefit consumers, it seemingly has not been clearly communicated to a sizeable portion of the company's primary audience, such as those who would watch Microsoft Tech Community YouTube videos.

Robert Carnevale

Robert Carnevale is the News Editor for Windows Central. He's a big fan of Kinect (it lives on in his heart), Sonic the Hedgehog, and the legendary intersection of those two titans, Sonic Free Riders. He is the author of Cold War 2395. Have a useful tip? Send it to robert.carnevale@futurenet.com.

Read more
Intel 9th Gen chip sticker on a laptop
The latest Windows 11 update did not end support for older Intel chips. Here's the source of the confusion.
Binary code displayed on a laptop screen and Guy Fawkes mask are seen in this illustration photo.
Microsoft blocks critical Secure Boot loophole after over 7 months — fortifying Windows 11 against sophisticated firmware attacks camouflaged as verified UEFI apps
Windows 11 Settings app about page
Windows 11 has a hidden FAQ page in testing that tells you why your PC is slow
Windows 11 Taskbar closeup
Microsoft doubles down on Windows 11 — calls for major Copilot+ PC upgrade cycle in 2025
Windows 10 to 11 upgrade preparation
How to prepare your Windows 10 PC for the Windows 11 upgrade
Windows 11 Taskbar closeup
Windows 11 hits a new market share milestone as Windows 10's death looms on the horizon
Latest in Windows 11
Photo of Microsoft's new sign-in page for Xbox.com using the Microsoft Edge browser.
Over one billion users will get a new Microsoft user experience, and it has a dark mode
Windows Update
Microsoft begins testing next phase of Windows 11 — Dev Channel to flight new platform changes
Windows 11 Search
Copilot+ PCs' first must-have feature is just around the corner
Themes section of the Microsoft Store on Windows 11
Two of my least favorite things about the Microsoft Store are about to get fixed
Surface Laptop 7
Amazon warns Surface Laptop 7 shoppers as Mojang unveils massive visual update to Minecraft and Microsoft leaks a potential new feature for the Xbox app on Windows 11
Windows 11 Update Settings
Your PC might have been blocked from updating Windows 11 because of this game
Latest in News
Cloud servers
Microsoft has killed "several" data center projects in the U.S. and Europe, according to reports — Microsoft responds (Updated)
Photo of Microsoft's new sign-in page for Xbox.com using the Microsoft Edge browser.
Over one billion users will get a new Microsoft user experience, and it has a dark mode
The Thing: Remastered key art
The Thing comes to Xbox Cloud Gaming's "Stream Your Own Game" library alongside other new arrivals
Promotional screenshot of heroes fighting a giant in Pillars of Eternity
Obsidian's classic Baldur's Gate successor 'Pillars of Eternity' is getting a surprise turn-based mode later this year, alongside other updates
Atomfall
Atomfall reviews and Metacritic scores are in: Here's a roundup of what everyone's saying about this new Game Pass survival game
Screenshot of one of the new flat world presets in Minecraft.
Minecraft testing new flat world presets and a better way to locate your friends in-game