Surface Laptop 4 vs. Surface Book 3: Which is a better buy?

The new Surface Laptop 4 features the latest 11th-generation Intel Core i5 and i7 processors, or a customized version of AMDs Ryzen 4000 series R5 or R7 chips. While the Surface Book 3 is rocking Intel's last generation Intel chips, it still have a more powerful GPU in the form of the NVIDIA GTX 1650 and 1660 Ti Max-Q cards. Also, the Book 3 is a 2-in-1 detachable, and has a higher-resolution display. Both are some of the best Surface PCs on the market, but which one should you get?

Surface Laptop 4 vs. Surface Book 3: Specifications

What's new with the Surface Laptop 4

• Intel 11th Gen Core processors with Iris Xe Graphics
• AMD Ryzen 4000 and Radeon Graphics (Surface Edition)
• Up to 32GB of RAM and 1TB storage (Intel only)
• No more 128GB option (256GB or higher)
• Dolby Atmos spatial-audio
• Ice Blue with Alcantara (13.5-inch Intel only)
• Up to 70% performance improvement
• Battery improvements
• Slightly faster Windows Hello login
• 15-inch models are only Core i7 or AMD Ryzen 7
• AMD models now have Wi-Fi 6 and LPDDR4x

Surface Laptop 4 vs. Surface Book 3: Design & Display

The designs of the Surface Laptop 4 and the Surface Book 3 couldn't be more different. One is a traditional ultrabook laptop, and the other is a 2-in-1 detachable with a unique hinge design. They're both available in 13.5-inch and 15-inch variants, but that's pretty much where the similarities end.

Surface Laptop 4 features an aluminum chassis, with some models coming with an Alcantara fabric keyboard base. You can also get the Surface Laptop 4 in multiple colors including Platinum, Black, Sandstone, and Ice Blue. The Surface Book 3 featurs a magnesium chassis, with no option for an Alcantara keyboard deck and only one color to choose from: Platinum.

The display's are also quite different, with the Surface Book 3 featuring a noticably brighter and higher resolution screen. That doesn't mean the display on the Surface Laptop 4 is bad, but if you're looking for the best display on a Surface, the Surface Book 3 is the one to go for.

Surface Laptop 4 vs. Surface Book 3: Performance

The Surface Laptop 4 ships with Intels latest 11th-generation Core i5 and i7 processors, but you can also get it with a specialized Microsoft Surface Edition AMD Ryzen 5 or Ryzen 7 4000 series processor. These chips are quite the jump in performance over the 10th-generation chip found in the Surface Book 3, offering better single and multi-thread app performance for a smoother multitasking and data processing experience.

That said, the 10th-generation chip in the Surface Book 3 isn't bad at all, and you won't really notice a difference in performance in day-to-day tasks. It's a different story in the graphics department however, as the Surface Book 3 ships with dedicated NVIDIA graphics, unlike the Surface Laptop 4 with its Integrated Iris Xe and RX Radeon graphics.

The integrated graphics are a huge improvement over the Surface Laptop 3, but compared to the Surface Book 3, it's no contest. The dedicated GTX 1650 and 1660 Ti Max-Q will outperform the Surface Laptop 4 every time. So, if you want to do heavy video editing of even some gaming, the Book 3 is the one to get.

Surface Laptop 4 vs. Surface Book 3: Pricing

Microsoft is pricing the Surface Laptop 4 at $999 for the base model, which is consideribly less than the starting price for the Surface Book 3, which comes in at $1,599. The entry-level Surface Book comes with just 8GB RAM and is without the dedicated graphics card, so you might be better served with the cheaper Surface Laptop 4 at that point.

Surface Laptop 4 is a beautiful Ultrabook

If you're looking for a traditional laptop with the latest specs, great battery life, and a beautiful design, the Surface Laptop 4 is an excellent choice.

Buy the Surface Book 3 for more graphics power

If you're in need of a 2-in-1 device that's also a great laptop, with a beautiful high-resolution display and real graphics power for on-the-go work and play, the Surface Book 3 is for you.