Microsoft says 'innovation will suffer' if Epic v. Apple ruling is upheld

Microsoft logo
Microsoft logo (Image credit: Daniel Rubino / Windows Central)

What you need to know

  • Microsoft, 35 states, and the U.S. Department of Justice have submitted filings to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit regarding the Epic v. Apple case.
  • Generally, the filings claim that the original ruling revolved around a misinterpretation of the Sherman Act, which is a law that bans monopolies.
  • Apple and Epic Games have also filed appeals to the original ruling.

The Epic Games v. Apple saga continues, now with added input from Microsoft, 35 states, and the United States Department of Justice (DoJ). All of the aforementioned groups recently submitted legal filings disputing the original ruling of the Epic v. Apple case (via ZDNet). The arguments of the filings center around the belief that the original ruling by District Judge Yvonne Gonzales-Rogers misinterpreted the Sherman Act, which is a law put in place to prevent monopolies and anti-competitive practices.

"The district court's holding creates a paralyzing paradox: Once a firm acquires market power and unilaterally imposes a contract, then it is no longer subject to Section 1. Affirming this paradox would gut the Sherman Act and prevent the Amici States from enforcing antitrust violations by large firms that harm their citizens," said the filing by the attorneys general representing the 35 states.

The filing from the DoJ made similar arguments, claiming that the original ruling "committed several legal errors that could imperil effective antitrust enforcement, especially in the digital economy." The DoJ added that "if upheld, [the ruling] could significantly harm competition and consumers by allowing a minor benefit to condone a major harm."

"Apple uses its control over an essential component of modern communications technology — now the phones, rather than the phone network — to interfere with how its customers may deal with third parties in other markets," said Microsoft in its briefing.

Microsoft's briefing also argues that Apple has already done damage. "Consumers and innovation will suffer — indeed, they already have. The district court's reasoning failed to give sufficient weight to these immense competitive risks and, if broadly affirmed, could insulate Apple from meritorious antitrust scrutiny and embolden further harmful conduct."

This is just the latest development in a case that's had countless twists and turns since its inception. Check out our full rundown of all the biggest Epic v. Apple bombshells to drop from the case to find out how Walmart, Nintendo, and other companies have been roped into the legal vortex.

CATEGORIES
Sean Endicott
News Writer and apps editor

Sean Endicott is a tech journalist at Windows Central, specializing in Windows, Microsoft software, AI, and PCs. He's covered major launches, from Windows 10 and 11 to the rise of AI tools like ChatGPT. Sean's journey began with the Lumia 740, leading to strong ties with app developers. Outside writing, he coaches American football, utilizing Microsoft services to manage his team. He studied broadcast journalism at Nottingham Trent University and is active on X @SeanEndicott_ and Threads @sean_endicott_. 

Read more
Google Chrome on PC
DOJ demands divestiture of Chrome browser and sets sights on making Google sell Android — calls Google "incompatible with free markets and freedom"
Sam Altman and Satya Nadella on stage
Microsoft's OpenAI "tech bromance" dodges UK merger probe — as it builds in-house models and tests DeepSeek in Copilot to break away from the ChatGPT maker
Snapdragon X Elite logo
Arm withdraws threat against Qualcomm that could have seen Copilot+ PCs with Snapdragon chips destroyed
Xbox app screenshots
Xbox pledges to double down on Windows improvements for gamers, as Valve's Steam OS turns up the heat — now faced with real competition, it's time for Windows to change
Palworld character holding Meowmere sword with Mozzarina lying dead in background
Nintendo applying for anti-Palworld patents in the US with a whopping 22 out of 23 rejected, but "they are fighting"
Bill Gates during the "I Could Jump It" sketch on The Tonight Show starring Jimmy Fallon
Bill Gates talks about trading for Windows 10 as Avowed wows reviewers and Microsoft kills HoloLens and lies about uninstalling Edge
Latest in Apple
Apple Intelligence running on an iPhone
Apple faces legal action for using "false" Apple Intelligence ads to drive iPhone 16 sales
Read Bruce Sewell's opening statement for the House Judiciary Committee
Apple will reportedly bring ChatGPT and Google Gemini under its Apple Intelligence and iOS 18 umbrella this fall — potentially prompting more iPhone sales
Apple logo
Apple will reportedly pay OpenAI with 'exposure' to hundreds of millions of its devices for the ChatGPT plug
Apple Intelligence logo
Apple becomes the world's most valuable company (again) ahead of Microsoft after recently unveiling its AI strategy
Apple logo with robots
Apple is gearing up to take on Microsoft in the AI space, per new job listings
Bing Chat running on the iPhone SE
Apple is working on its own ChatGPT AI alternative to compete with Bing Chat and Google Bard
Latest in News
Microsoft Xbox Elite Wireless Series 2
Amazon warns customers which Xbox products are "frequently returned items," and one is particularly unsurprising
Windows 11 Wallpaper
Microsoft publishes Windows roadmap as it promises transparency around feature availability
Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 Zombies mode screenshots for Shattered Veil map.
The next Call of Duty Zombies map, "Shattered Veil", is dropping earlier than expected
Helldivers 2
The new Helldivers 2 Illuminate Major Order is so important that we got a new stratagem for it
Hogwarts Legacy troll hero image
Hogwarts Legacy DLC reportedly canceled by WB Games
Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Siege
Rumored Ubisoft and Tencent agreement comes to fruition with 25% stake and new division for the Assassin's Creed developer