Lenovo Legion Go S vs ASUS ROG Ally: Which handheld is better?

The original white ASUS ROG Ally, which launched in 2023, was the first major gaming handheld to run Windows 11. I was the one who conducted testing and wrote up both our ROG Ally review and ROG Ally X review for Windows Central. Since then, multiple competitors have come out of the woodwork, including the Legion Go line.

With the new Legion Go S on the market, I decided I wanted to see how Lenovo's new device compares to ROG Ally. Now that my colleague, Zachary Boddy, has done their Legion Go S review, I was able to compare the two handhelds more precisely.

In case you don't know, there are two versions of the Legion Go S — the white Legion Go S (8" , 1), which runs Windows 11, and the Nebula Violet (dark purple) Legion Go S — Powered by SteamOS (8" , 1) that runs (you guessed it) SteamOS. Here's how the Legion Go S compares to the ROG Ally.

Legion Go S vs ROG Ally: Specs

Now that you've had a chance to look over the comparison chart, lets go over these different point and explain more thoroughly how they impact the user experience.

Back to the top ^

Legion Go S vs ROG Ally: Price & value

As I previously explained, the Lenovo Legion Go S has both a Windows 11 version that sells for $729.99 and then, in May, a $499.99 SteamOS version. Meanwhile, the ROG Ally only has Windows 11 as an operating system. Of course, there's also the larger Legion Go, which has a starting price of $699.99 at Best Buy.

There are two Ally options: An Ally with an AMD Ryzen Z1 processor that sells for $499.99 and a beefier Z1 Extreme Ally that sells for $649.99. It's also worth noting that the improved ROG Ally X has a starting price of $799.99 at Best Buy and features a Z1 Extreme, 24GB RAM, and 1TB SSD

You should note that the ROG Ally regularly gets discounted (I've seen it up to $200 off at Best Buy) during special sales events like Black Friday and Prime Day, whereas the Legion Go gaming handhelds haven't seen as good of discounts. So, if you happen to buy a device during a sale period, you're more likely to get a better deal for ROG Ally, if this trend holds true.

Obviously, the SteamOS Legion Go S is the least expensive, so it might be the best option for anyone on a budget. However, between the Windows 11 Ally and Go S devices, the ROG Ally Z1 is the less expensive handheld. That said, I'd recommend going with the $649.99 ROG Ally Z1 Extreme over the plain Z1; even though it costs more, it's still cheaper than the Legion Go S Z2 Go. Because of this, I'd consider the ROG Ally the best value buy in this instance.

To be clear, the Legion Go S Windows handheld costs more because it offers newer features. It has a larger screen, dual Thunderbolt ports, more RAM, higher capacity SSD storage, and a larger battery than ROG Ally. However, when it comes to battery and performance, you'll get a better value from ROG Ally (more on that later).

TL;DR: PRICE WINNER: There's no denying that the Legion Go S (SteamOS) costs much less than the ROG Ally. However, if you're looking for the most value for your buck then the ROG Ally Z1 Extreme is the best pick.

Back to the top ^

Legion Go S vs ROG Ally: Performance

In case you don't know, the AMD Z2 Go chip offered with Legion Go S is custom silicon only available in Lenovo devices. In other words, we won't ever see it in another handheld. This brings unique challenges that only Legion Go S users will face compared to those with handhelds that have more widely owned processors.

In my colleague's Legion Go S review, they analyzed AMD Z2 Go performance to see how it compares against the Z1 and Z1 Extreme chips. Lenovo previously stated that the Z2 Go offers better power consumption than the Z1 Extreme but isn't as powerful as it. However, our own findings didn't match this.

The Go S offers 32GB RAM and 1TB SSD, while the ROG Ally only has 16GB RAM and 512GB SSD. Still, the ROG Ally Z1 Extreme performed better in our benchmarks and testing than the Go S did. Games played smoother, too.

TL;DR: PERFORMANCE WINNER: The ROG Ally Z1 Extreme offers better performance than the Z2 Go Legion Go S (Windows 11).

Back to the top ^

Legion Go S vs ROG Ally: Display

Both Legion Go S models have an 8-inch, LCD, 16:10, touchscreen that can reach up to a resolution of 1920 x 1200, a brightness of 500 nits, and a refresh rate of 120Hz. Lenovo also claims that the display produces a very nice color gamut of 97% of DCI-P3, but in our own testing, it got 78% of P3. The computer manufacturer also learned from its previous gen's mistakes and has made sure that the Legion Go S display supports both VRR and native landscape. These are all very nice features to have.

Meanwhile, the ROG Ally has a smaller 7-inch, IPS LED, 16:9, touchscreen that can reach up to 1920 x 1080, the same 500 nits of brightness, and the same 120Hz refresh rate. In my own colorimeter testing, the Ally's screen produced a much lower 73% of P3, but it still looks good in person. Of course, the ROG Ally also supports VRR and native landscape, which helps the device produce better motion clarity in gaming.

TL;DR: DISPLAY WINNER: The Legion Go S not only has the larger display that supports VRR and native landscape, but it also has a slightly better color gamut as well.

Back to the top ^

Legion Go S vs ROG Ally: Controls and ports

Image 1 of 5

When you put the ROG Ally and the Legion Go S (Windows) side-by-side, the devices look relatively similar, with many of the buttons, bumpers, triggers, and controls in the same places. However, there are some key differences that make it obvious that the Go S has a better design than the Ally.

For one, the Legion Go S offers Hall Effect joysticks, which should never suffer from drift. This is something that is lacking in the ROG Ally. Although, there haven't been that many reports of drift in the ASUS handheld.

Additionally, the Legion Go S has a small touchpad on the right side under the joystick, whereas the Ally does not. Lastly, the Go S has adjustable trigger switches on the back to give more custom control. The one thing that ROG Ally has that the Go S doesn't is a fingerprint reader. It doesn't always work correctly, but it can be very nice to have when it does. In case you're wondering, the Legion Go 2 prototype does have a fingerprint reader.

While I'm talking about the Legion Go 2, the Go S does not have the larger device's detachable controllers, nor does it have a kickstand. These are features in common with the Ally. If you're interested, you can learn more about these handheld differences in our Legion Go 2 vs Legion Go S comparison.

It's also worth noting that the SteamOS version of the Go S will have a specific Steam button, whereas the Windows 11 version has a Legion Space button.

The Go S also outshines the original ROG Ally when it comes to ports. ASUS only included one USB-C 3.2 Gen 2 port that also works as a combo port for the company's ROG XG Mobile eGPU accessory. Meanwhile, Go S offers two USB4 ports, which makes it easy to charge the device with one port and plug in a different accessory with the other.

TL;DR: CONTROLS & PORTS WINNER: Since the Legion Go S offers Hall Effect joysticks, a touchpad, adjustable trigger switches, and two USB4 type-C ports, it has the better layout between the two handhelds.

Back to the top ^

Legion Go S vs ROG Ally: Software and games

Like the Steam Deck, the SteamOS version of the Go S is built to access your Steam library in a way that's more reminiscent of a simplified console interface. However, that means that it isn't set up to access other PC gaming services out of the box. You can definitely make adjustments to the Linux-based operating system so that you can play games on Xbox Game Pass, Battle.net, Epic Games, and more, but it will take some work to make that happen.

Meanwhile, the Windows Go S model and the ROG Ally both run Windows 11 and act just like a laptop (sans keyboard). This means you can do a lot with these devices, such as using a browser to navigate to other gaming services, downloading launchers, or accessing game files. The thing is, you might also have to deal with Windows 11 troubleshooting, which some find offputting on handhelds. Of course, we at Windows Central have a bunch of Windows 11 guides if you need any assistance with any of that.

The Ally comes with Armoury Crate installed, while the Go S comes with Legion Space. These applications let you adjust system settings while also serving as game launchers and stores. There are pros and cons to both software, but at the moment, Armoury Crate offers better customization options, including the ability to adjust VRAM. Weirdly enough, you have to go into the Go S BIOS in order to change VRAM, which isn't ideal.

Since both devices use AMD chips, it's also in your best interest to use AMD Software on the Windows handhelds, a program that gives additional control over either system. This is where you'll go to enable things like AMD Fluid Motion Frames 2 (AFMF 2), Anti-lag, and other performance-boosting features.

TL;DR: SOFTWARE & GAMES WINNER: You could argue that Legion Go S offers better options to choose from since it will have both a SteamOS and Windows version. However, ROG Ally's Armoury Crate provides better settings and customization options. So, between the two Windows devices, ROG Ally is better.

Back to the top ^

Legion Go S vs ROG Ally: Battery life

Gaming handhelds are pretty notorious when it comes to battery life.; It's one of the worst areas of these devices. As it is, the first-gen Windows 11 gaming handhelds, like ROG Ally, typically don't last more than an hour at max TPD when playing graphically demanding games. That's not ideal.

Meanwhile, the Go S only lasts roughly 30 minutes longer than Ally due to it having a larger 55.5 Whr battery compared to Ally's 40 Whr battery. As such, neither device really offers satisfactory battery life. The best handheld on the market right now, battery-wise, is the ROG Ally X, which lasted 2 hours and 10 minutes in our own battery life testing while playing demanding games.

TL;DR: BATTERY LIFE WINNER: Neither device really has amazing battery life. Of the two Legion Go S is slightly better, but ROG Ally X lasts even longer.

Back to the top ^

Legion Go S vs ROG Ally: Grip ergonomics and comfort

When you look at the ROG Ally and Legion Go S side-by-side, Lenovo's device looks a lot more rounded. This is interesting, considering that the Ally looks a lot more rounded compared to the blocky, original Legion Go. Still, both devices offer really nice ergonomic designs that are even more comfortable to hold than you might think.

In terms of size and weight, the Go S is a slightly bigger device. It's 11.77 inches wide, 5.02 inches tall, 0.89 inches deep, and weighs 1.61 pounds. Meanwhile, the Ally is 11.02 inches wide, 4.37 inches tall, 0.83 inches deep, and weighs in at 1.34 pounds.

The gripping area on the Legion Go S is more rounded and thicker, while the ROG Ally is more angular and has a slanted area in front to better make way for your palms. That said, the Ally's large back buttons awkwardly edge into the gripping area, which makes this smaller handheld a bit less comfortable to hold than the Legion Go S. This was something that was adjusted for the ROG Ally X.

TL;DR: COMFORT WINNER: The Legion Go S has a great ergonomic shape to its casing, and the back buttons don't get in the way of your grip like the Ally's back buttons do.

Back to the top ^

Legion Go S vs ROG Ally: Comparison chart

Back to the top ^

Legion Go S vs ROG Ally: Which should I buy?

Image 1 of 2

In the end, there are some major tradeoffs between going with the Legion Go S or the ROG Ally. Either gaming handheld could be a great pick, depending on what you value most in your gaming device.

The Legion Go S (SteamOS) is the least expensive option and will offer the simplest interface. As such, it's ideal for anyone on a budget or who wants a handheld that operates similarly to a console.

That said, if you're more interested in getting a handheld that offers better performance, then the ROG Ally Z1 Extreme is your best bet. It might not have the best battery life, but it can play many of the latest AAA games relatively smoothly. Of course, if you play plugged in or with the handheld connected to a docking station, then you won't have to worry about battery life. Alternatively, if you really care about battery life, you might want to get an Ally X.

I can't deny that the Go S feels great in your hands and offers better controls than ROG Ally and the original Legion Go. However, at this time, we cannot fully recommend the Legion Go S (Windows 11) with a Z2 Go chip due to the fact that it is more expensive than the original Legion Go and ROG Ally. What's more, its Z2 Go chip offers lower performance than those Z1 Extreme devices.

Back to the top ^