Welcome to our best Xbox controller article, fully updated and ready for the upcoming 2024 holiday season. Our number one pick and best overall is the Xbox Wireless Controller, which is available at most electronics retailers. We've also highlighted five other controllers as the best option in various use cases.
Picking out the best Xbox controller is getting increasingly complex. In recent months, Microsoft lifted the restrictions it had in place for Xbox One and Xbox Series X|S controllers, which gave them a defacto monopoly over wirelessness.
Recent updates
December 4, 2024: Black Friday and Cyber Monday have concluded, and I removed the extra buying advice focusing on the shopping events. — Jennifer Young
Across the Windows Central team, we spend thousands of hours a year playing video games, and each controller, headset, and other accessories enjoy dozens of hours of extensive testing for our in-depth expert reviews.
To that end, third-party controller makers like Razer, Turtle Beach, or GameSir, generally couldn't use wireless modes in their controllers. There were a few exceptions, relating to patent amnesties and things like that, but generally speaking, if you wanted wireless you had to buy from Xbox and Microsoft.
Times have changed, though. More than ever, third-party players are building wireless options for Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One, giving "Player 2" a better experience than ever. Of course, every Xbox Series X|S purchase comes with a standard Xbox controller in the box, but what if your dog ate it and you need a replacement? What if you want an Xbox controller that simply does more? Well, look no further, friend.
I've personally tested dozens of Xbox controllers over the years, and have worked with my colleagues at Windows Central to bring you this wide-ranging guide into the best Xbox controllers money can buy. Generally speaking, all Xbox controllers also work on PC, thanks to the synergy between Windows and Xbox, so this is also a good guide if you're looking for a new PC gamepad as well.
Here's an in-depth look at our top picks for best Xbox controllers and gamepads for a variety of user scenarios, budgets, and niches. — Jez Corden, Managing Editor
The quick list
Here's a list of our top six picks, representing the best of the best in each category of Xbox controllers. From the standard Xbox controller to more specialized picks like the Thrustmaster, these controllers beat out everything else we've laid our hands on. If you want more details on each pick and why we chose it, you can click each link to fast-forward to the full descriptions.
The standard Xbox Series X|S controller offers the perfect balance of performance and value for money. While you can stick with the stock controller that comes with your console, there is also a seemingly endless range of colors and designs for most tastes. Its weight is well balanced, buttons are perfectly positioned, and the addition of the share button this gen makes taking game captures a breeze. We recommend the Vapor range in particular because of the inclusion of rubber grips on the rear, making this ergonomic controller even more comfortable to use.
GameSir has steadily built a reputation for delivering high value in the sub-$50 controller space, and the GameSir G7 SE boasts components like Hall effect sticks that outperform and outlast the standard Xbox controller, and anti-friction rings and rear remappable buttons. The only thing holding this controller back from topping our list is that it's wired, which isn't convenient for most — but if that's not a deal breaker for you and you want the best a low budget can get, this is it.
We've long lauded Razer's Wolverine controller range, and its first wireless model has impressed us to no end. The inclusion of Hall effect sticks for eradicating stick drift, Razer mouse switch technology, and the ability to unlock 1000 Hz polling when used with a PC push this a few steps ahead of Xbox's own Elite controller if you are looking for something to give you a competitive advantage.
The official Xbox Elite Series's premium feel is unmatched by any third-party competitors. It has a hefty price tag but has come down in sales in recent years to make it a little more accessible. The Elite Series 2 has a satisfying weight and exquisitely designed components, such as the magnetic analog sticks and D-pad you can pop off and switch to your preference. The real bang for your buck here is the 40-hour battery life and inclusion of a wireless charging dock.
If you've ever really wanted to customize a controller on the fly— perhaps move the sticks from asymmetric to side-by-side or switch out the D-Pad—then a modular controller like the ESwap X Pro is the perfect solution for you. With a controller that lets you switch everything around, you can configure it to exactly your needs. There's even a Forza Horizon version with a wheel, and the parts are swappable between all of the models.
The GameSir G8 Galileo is one of many options for mobile gaming controllers for Xbox Cloud Gaming. It's much cheaper than its Razer and Backbone competitors and offers full-size grips and seriously satisfying buttons and sticks. If you want something to comfortably turn your mobile into a handheld, rivaling the likes of the PS Portal and Logitech G Cloud, you can do it with this or the alternative G8 Plus, which connects with Bluetooth and offers wider compatibility for folding phones.
How we chose the best Xbox and Windows PC controllers
When looking for a controller, we're looking for compatibility with Xbox—it seems like a no-brainer, but many controllers advertise as 'Xbox layout' but do not actually work with Microsoft's console. We also look at the price of each controller to determine if we feel it's worth what the manufacturer is asking after conducting our own testing. For instance, a $30 controller may be cheap, but is it worth it if the controller's build quality isn't up to scratch? The answer is probably not if you have to constantly replace them.
✅Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, and PC compatibility
✅Price and relative value
✅Features like Bluetooth and mobile support
We also consider any additional features an Xbox Series X|S controller offers over its counterparts before deciding whether it deserves our 'best in slot' accolade. For example, PowerA may be in a similar price bracket to GameSir, but we often choose the latter for including Hall effect sticks, which makes them a better value.
There are also things to consider, like compatibility. Xbox has a strange history with third-party controllers, previously maintaining a monopoly over wireless access. But that restriction was lifted this year, leading to a broader variety of options for users looking to get more out of their wireless Xbox controller experience. We test dozens of these devices every year over long periods of time to help you make the best choices for you. — Jennifer Young
The best overall Xbox and PC controller
- Read our in-depth Xbox Wireless Controller review
You can't beat old faithful, which is why for most, I think the standard Xbox Series X|S Wireless Controller remains the best option. It's the easiest to replace with almost infinite stock, and it's supremely comfortable, balanced, and light to hold over long periods of time. It is heavily supported by Microsoft since it's the company's home-grown option, and it has a truly huge variety of compatibility capabilities. It comes with the Xbox Series X|S bundled into the price too, so you probably already have one. But if not, it has an MSRP (recommended price) of $69.99, but can be found selling for $59.99 at Amazon and other major retailers.
The Xbox Series X|S Wireless Controller also works with Xbox One and Windows PCs as well via USB cable or Bluetooth. You can also grab a cheap Xbox Wireless Dongle to use the more reliable Xbox Wireless signal, which beats Bluetooth for responsiveness but having to purchase anything separately is always a tad annoying. If you're interested, you can buy the Xbox Wireless Adapter for $24.99 at Walmart and other major retailers.
Indeed, the biggest downside probably of the standard Xbox Wireless Controller is the lack of internal battery. While the aftermarket Xbox rechargeable battery options are broad and various, it can be difficult to find an option that is actually decent quality over time. It's for this reason I actually, in the end, just went with the Xbox Wireless Elite Controller Series 2 for that monster battery life — but you do pay a premium there. The whole point of the Xbox Series X|S standard controller is that it is monstrously affordable and versatile.
RELATED: Best Xbox controller chargers
Speaking of versatility, I mentioned that it's compatible with PC via USB and Bluetooth, but it's also compatible with iPad, iPhone, and Android devices via USB and Bluetooth as well. This makes it a great option for playing on Xbox Cloud Gaming, complete with full "native" support for the Xbox button opening the guide menu and the like. The Xbox controller is often regarded as the "standard" option for many PC games as well, including services like NVIDIA GeForce Now, although PlayStation's offering has become more broadly compatible too there in recent years.
The Xbox Wireless Controller doesn't sport Hall effect inputs, which means it can be susceptible to drift over long periods of time. There has also been some notorious quality issues with the bumpers, although it's often more related to dust getting into the controller over time. To that end, it's good then that the Xbox Wireless Controller is perhaps the easiest-to-repair option on the market (like this Joreswt 38PCs Repair Kit selling for $9.99 at Amazon). Opening the controller is easy with any pry tool or even a knife (if you're careful), making internal cleaning pretty simple, as long as you follow a guide.
The Xbox Wireless Controller is updated frequently via the Xbox Accessories app on both Xbox and PC, and has long been the standard go-to pick for best gamepad across both platforms. — Jez Corden
| Attribute | Rating & notes |
|---|---|
| Value | 4.5 — For $59.99 this controller will faithfully accompany you across thousands of hours of play on multiple devices. |
| Design | 4.5 — While the design needs a bit of a modern refresh, it is the standard bearer for all gamepads for many years. |
| Connectivity | 5 — This is where Xbox gets top marks, with Bluetooth, Xbox Wireless, USB wired, across virtually every platform. This is a connectivity powerhouse. |
| Features | 4.5 — Microsoft could do a bit more here, especially given the multi-device world Xbox wants to live in, but the versatility cannot be understated. |
The best budget Xbox and PC controller
GameSir has steadily made a name for itself, designing and releasing affordable, quality controllers that bring high-end features down to lower price points. The GameSir G7 line represents the highest-performance controllers GameSir can make for Xbox and Windows PC, and they're genuinely some of my favorite controllers of all time. I originally reviewed the GameSir G7, then revisited that review when the SE variant was released sometime later. If this controller was wireless, we might be recommending it above Microsoft's own option.
The GameSir G7 SE is a lightweight, compact, plastic-clad, wired controller for Xbox and PC that comes in at just $44.99 at Amazon (with your choice of four colors, too), but the sheer quality and number of features you get at that price point is astounding. This controller is very comfortable to use for long periods of time; it features laser-etched grips, the faceplate is replaceable and paintable for added customization, and the controller is overall built great.
GameSir also employs Hall effect sensors in both the joysticks and the triggers, which basically replaces traditional analog mechanisms that are prone to wear, tear, and drift with electromagnets. This ensures a much longer lifespan than your average controller but also enables features like the "hair trigger" mode to make the triggers as responsive as possible in competitive games. You're getting a lot of other features, too: two remappable rear buttons and lock switches for them, audio controls integrated into the D-Pad, a 3.5mm audio jack, and support for the GameSir Nexus app on both Xbox and PC.
Unfortunately, this controller is still wired, so if you absolutely need to cut that cable, this won't be the best fit for you. If you don't mind being plugged in, though, I put the GameSir G7 SE over the Xbox Wireless Controller in overall performance and durability, which is an impressive feat for $45.
As an honorable mention, you can also consider the alternative GameSir G7 "HE," the latest variant that brings back the awesome tactile microswitches of the original G7 for the face buttons and D-Pad and replaces the laser-etched grips with silicone... at the expense of the rear button locks and an extra $5 out of your pocket. The GameSir G7 HE is available in both black and white for $49.99 at Amazon. — Zachary Boddy
| Attribute | Rating & notes |
|---|---|
| Value | 5 — For just $45 you're getting a comfortable, durable, and performant controller with some excellent extra features. |
| Design | 4.5 — The more compact design makes the G7 SE great for those with smaller hands, and in general this controller feels far more premium than its price would suggest. |
| Connectivity | 4 — Being limited to a wire is unfortunate, but it's at least a nice braided cable and the GameSir Nexus app is available on both Xbox and Windows PC. |
| Features | 5 — Hall effect sensors, anti-glide friction rings, remappable rear buttons with lock switches, integrated audio controls, software customization, an onboard "M" control button... What more do you need? |
The best premium Xbox and PC controller
The Razer Wolverine V3 Pro is what players have been dreaming of for years — a high-end, truly wireless Xbox and PC controller that gives the long-standing Xbox Elite Wireless Controller some serious competition. The Wolverine V3 Pro delivers the closest thing we have to perfection for hardcore and competitive gamers looking for the ultimate controller, although it is expensive, selling for $199.99 at Best Buy.
At least you get everything you need in the box, including the Razer Wolverine V3 Pro in its matte black glory, with its etched grips, six remappable buttons built on Razer mouse switches, Hall effect joysticks, triggers with a one-stage lock that activates the hidden tactile mouse switches for instant response, and the customizable glowing Razer logo. You also get a braided USB Type-C cable you can use for charging or wired connectivity (which also enables a 1,000Hz polling rate on PC), two alternative joystick caps, and a firm travel case.
Physically, the Wolverine V3 Pro appears similar to past Razer controllers. It's a different shape than the standard Xbox controller, but it's nearly as comfortable and is a little more suited for smaller hands. Build quality is also top-notch, and the controller feels supremely durable... With the minor exception that one of the rear paddles on my unit already feels a little loose after just a few weeks of use. Still, at the very least, you'll never have to worry about joystick drift.
Once you're connected, the Wolverine V3 Pro is a beast of a controller. It's perfectly responsive, with the joysticks and triggers feeling silky smooth and every button having a firm, tactile action that feels incredibly satisfying. There's no latency, and I've never experienced a disconnect, although it can take the Wolverine V3 Pro longer than it should to first connect when you power it on, and you lose a USB port to the HyperSpeed dongle.
This is an expensive controller, but it's worth it. My colleague Richard Devine wrote the majority of our Razer Wolverine V3 Pro review (I then contributed my own thoughts and testing) and stated, "If you've been holding out on getting a new controller because you're in the market for the best of the best, you're probably going to find it here."
If you don't need the wireless connectivity, though, you can save yourself some cash and get the Razer Wolverine V3 Tournament Edition for just $99.99 at Best Buy. This controller deserves an honorable mention because it shares the same core foundation and design as the Wolverine V3 Pro and basically just loses the wireless support and the glowing Razer logo for literally half the cost. Oh, and it still works with Xbox consoles. — Zachary Boddy
| Attribute | Rating & notes |
|---|---|
| Value | 4 — This is an expensive controller, but it's worth it if you truly want the best of the best (and need it to be wireless). |
| Design | 4.5 — This is a very comfortable design that in some ways surpasses Microsoft's own, but it falls just short of that level of ergonomic perfection. |
| Connectivity | 4.5 — Having true wireless support for Xbox and PC is awesome in addition to the wired fallback, but you have to rely on a dongle rather than true Xbox Wireless (and there's no Bluetooth support, either). |
| Features | 5 — As far as controllers are concerned, you can't include many more features than the Wolverine V3 Pro has. Six remappable buttons and short trigger stops (all using premium mouse switches) is unique. |
The best alternative Xbox and PC controller
- Read our in-depth Xbox Elite Controller (Series 2) review
Previously, we had the Xbox Elite Controller (Series 2) up as our "best" controller pick in a previous version of this article, but over time, some pretty egregious issues have reared their head with this setup.
It's true that not everybody experiences problems with the Xbox Elite Controller (Series 2), but I know far too many people with issues that it would be remiss not to mention them. The right bumper on the Xbox Elite Controller (Series 2) seems to have a shelf life of around 6-8 months, which is irritating when you can pay up to $199.99 at Amazon for this controller, depending on which bundle you pick. If you're willing to risk it, though (or repair it yourself, which is possible), this remains one of the best Xbox controllers money can buy today.
The Xbox Elite Controller (Series 2) is a personal favorite of mine. I've owned three of these things so far, one as a replacement and two for different work locations. The thing that makes it so good, for me, is the battery life and its complimentary charger. So few battery charging solutions offer true longevity or quality, and Microsoft absolutely nailed it here with a dock that works every single time and will keep your controller maxed out for infinite gaming sessions. With this controller, you will never have to worry about battery life or charging ever again.
It also sports familiar versatility to its standard cousin, with Bluetooth capabilities for PC, Android, and iOS, as well as Xbox Wireless and USB wired support on both Xbox and PC. The bundle version is $179.99 MSRP and comes with a carry case, the charging dock, back paddles, additional joysticks, and D-pad styles. The $139.99 "Core" version ditches the dock and extra buttons for a tidy ~$60 saving (or more, depending on where you buy). Plus, you can customize it to look the way you'd like via Xbox Design Lab.
It has hair trigger locks, which reduce the graded activation. In some games, you'll want (or even need) to feel the gradual pull of a trigger, but in fast-paced shooters, you'll want that travel distance reduced. That's where the trigger locks can be really handy. Similarly, the back buttons offer a tactical edge over the standard controller. In shooters, if you want to hit any of your ABXY buttons for reloading and the like, you need to take your finger off one of the movement sticks. With back buttons, you can keep your thumbs on the joysticks at all times, moving things like jumping and reloading to the back of the controller.
This would be a no-brainer recommendation if it weren't for the known issues with the right bumper. They are repairable with a pry tool and isopropanol since the issue generally pertains to the contacts getting dusty. But if you don't want the hassle, the Razer Wolverine V3 Pro we recommended above is a far "safer" option for now, it seems, even if it's a bit more expensive and has decreased battery life. — Jez Corden
| Attribute | Rating & notes |
|---|---|
| Value | 3.5 — The value rating takes a beating here because of the known bumper issues. The Xbox Elite Controller (Series 2) is known to have an average shelf life of around 6 months before the bumper will fail, requiring a repair. You can repair it yourself, but it's not as easy as repairing a standard controller. |
| Design | 4 — The design of the Xbox Elite Controller (Series 2) itself is fantastic, with monster battery life and high customizability. It's just that pesky right bumper... |
| Connectivity | 5 — Like its cheaper standard cousin, the fact you can use this controller on practically any device where Xbox exists is a big plus. |
| Features | 4.5 — Interchangeable sticks, trigger locks, Bluetooth, hardware profile buttons, and the best controller charge dock on the market make this a killer product. |
The best modular Xbox and PC controller
Thrustmaster, better known for its racing and flight sim hardware, has created something unique with the Eswap Pro X Controller. Whether you prefer different thumbstick configurations, D-pad styles, or even a racing wheel module, you can tailor the controller to your specific needs. This flexibility is particularly beneficial for gamers who play a variety of genres and want the best setup for each game. We tested the licensed Forza Horizon 5 version (XR), which has a module designed entirely for racing games.
The Thrustmaster Eswap XR Pro Forza Horizon 5 controller has an MSRP of $179.99 at Amazon. You get the controller, wheel module, tool to remove the D-Pad easily, braided cable, and a little carry bag. Alternatively, if you already have a compatible Eswap controller, the wheel module can be purchased on its own for just $29.99 at Amazon. Therein lies the beauty of the Thrustmaster Eswap range, you can buy extra modules and craft your perfect controller. Want to change from asymmetric sticks and play a symmetrical (PlayStation) layout? You can. Want to take out the D-pad and rock 3 sticks? You can do that with these controllers. The modules just pop out and pop back in where you want them.
For those looking for a pro-grade controller, it ticks all the boxes. You get built-in trigger stops, replaceable grips, software control over remapping buttons and sensitivity, and a customizable layout. The four buttons on the rear of the controller are automatically set to mirror the ABXY buttons on the controller but can be mapped to anything you like. This is particularly important when using the wheel module, as the rear buttons can be used in place of the D-Pad, which you can replace it with.
The modules slot into place and 'just work.' For example, the wheel module will instantly be recognized by any racing game you are playing, and you simply use it in place of a stick. However, you do have control over the controller settings in the ThrustmapperX application on Windows for some real tinkering.
Movements need to be more precise with the wheel, but the level of control you have feels so much more natural than using an analog stick. Specifically, for Forza Horizon 5, drifting is so much better than just using a regular analog stick. Not only does it feel more natural, but it’s also more responsive to fine movements to keep those streaks going.
If racing isn't your thing and you're looking at the plain black Thrustmaster Eswap X Pro, there are still endless ways to customize the modular controller outside of what you get in the box, with a bunch of packs available to really make it your own. The only real downside for the Thrustmaster is that it uses micro-USB, which is now pretty outdated, and that it's slightly larger than your average Xbox controller, so it's definitely not one for smaller hands.
If you're looking for a wireless modular option, we hear the PDP Victrix Pro BFG Wireless is making waves and has a 'fighting game' module, but we don't have personal experience with this controller as of yet. — Jennifer Young
| Attribute | Rating & notes |
|---|---|
| Value | 3.5 — This was always an expensive pick for a wireless controller but the quaility components made it worth it. We'd like to have seen some shift in the price by now, though. |
| Design | 4.5 — Thrustmaster have made something truly unique to each individual gamer by offering a modular design. |
| Connectivity | 2.5 — Wired isn't a a deal breaker, but we are disappointed it's a micro-USB. |
| Features | 4 — From customizing the individual components to a generous 4 remappable buttons, this controller has a lot of extra features. |
The best mobile and Xbox Cloud Gaming controller
- Read our in-depth GameSir G8 Galileo review and GameSir G8 Galileo Plus review
The GameSir G8 Galileo is a mobile gaming controller that connects via USB-C, transforming your phone into a handheld console. Don't want to shell out for a Steam Deck or a ROG Ally? You can play games from your mobile phone with this controller if you have a decent internet connection for Xbox Cloud Gaming or want to play mobile games.
It features an Xbox-like layout with asymmetric sticks, a D-pad, and four face buttons, along with hall-effect sticks and two additional rear buttons for customizable remapping. The controller also includes a USB-C port for pass-through charging and comes with the GameSir app for easy control mapping which comes in clutch for games that want you to use touchscreen controls.
Priced at $79.99, the GameSir G8 Galileo is nearly half the price of mobile controllers such as the Razer Kishi Ultra, and I think the price point is more appropriate for the mobile gaming space. The package includes the controller, instructions, stickers, and even three customized thumbstick options. The controller’s design, similar to a split Xbox controller, offers superior comfort, with full-size buttons and triggers enhancing the ergonomic experience, though the sticks are slightly smaller and in line with other handheld devices. As ever, GameSir has packed in Hall-effect technology in the triggers and joysticks to provide precision and durability. It's $79.99, and you likely won't be replacing it unless you change to an incompatible mobile device. That said, it should work with most standard-sized phones out there.
I've winced many times at trying to squeeze my expensive smartphone into one of these controllers. Thankfully, GameSir has included a pivoting USB-C connector this time around to make it easier to slip your phone in and out of the casing, and the rubberized base prevents the phone from sliding around. I did note with both this and the Bluetooth edition that if you have a phone with a protruding rear camera (the Google Pixel 9, for example), you may not get on with this as the phone needs to sit flush in the case. If that sounds like it would be an issue, there are split-design mobile controllers like this Turtle Beach Atom Controller for $79.99 at Amazon that may be better suited.
Now, back to the GameSir G8. The rear of the controller features two removable buttons if you want to customize it to a more comfortable setup. However, the triggers and bumpers feel somewhat hollow in construction, but I've yet to find a mobile controller that really impresses me in the trigger department! The G8 Plus model, which connects via Bluetooth, has a couple of improvements, like a rumble motor and 6-axis gyroscope, for the same $79.99 price, and it will also accommodate a folding phone. I chose the G8 as the winner in this category over the Plus; however, I personally prefer a device I don't need to think about charging separately to my phone, so the USB-C connectivity wins out for me. — Jennifer Young
| Attribute | Rating & notes |
|---|---|
| Value | 4.5 — It is priced competitively against rival controllers from brands like Razer. |
| Design | 4.5 — Having full size sticks and a button that lights up depending on configuration makes this design stand out. |
| Connectivity | 4 — The USB-C connection means you don't have to worry about charging. |
| Features | 4 — Packing Hall effect components into a mobile controller is admirable and it has remappable buttons too. |
The honorable mentions
In testing the myriad of Xbox and third-party controllers on the market, it's pretty tough to pick the best of the best, but we thought it pertinent to mention the runners-up for consideration. The Xbox controller market is increasingly competitive, and just because a controller isn't listed as our top pick, it doesn't mean it's not worth a look. Here are some other controllers we like that didn't make the top 6.
This was actually our choice for the best 'pro' option until Razer came along to eat its lunch. The Stealth Ultra is a wireless controller designed with competitive gaming in mind, with the ability to tailor the controller to racing or shooters with its fine aim adjustments. Some may still prefer the Turtle Beach option with its built-in 1.4-inch color display for onboard customization and receiving social notifications — but the Razer edged ahead with its more no-frills design. $199.99 at Best Buy.
• Read our in-depth Turtle Beach Stealth Ultra review
Probably the most impressive mobile controller we've ever laid our hands-on, the Kishi Ultra narrowly misses the top spot purely down to its premium price tag. However, if money is no object and you want an opulent controller for Xbox Cloud Gaming and Nvidia GeForce Now, this Kishi, with its audio-based haptics, RGB Chroma, and Nexus software, offers a top-class experience. Priced at $149.99.
• Read our in-depth Razer Kishi Ultra review
This controller takes the Xbox controller design and makes it 'smol', which is fantastic for kids. Available in black or lilac, with long, sturdy cable, the PowerA Nano doesn't have any fancy details, and neither does it need to. It's simply a compact controller that can take a bit of roughhousing from boisterous mini-gamers and won't cost the earth. Priced at $39.99.
• Read our in-depth PowerA Nano review
For a controller that doesn't fade into the background, the PowerA Advantage with its Lumectra lighting can be purchased alone or with an included strip of lights as a value entry into the world of RGB gaming setups. It's an update to the popular Spectra controllers of yester year with the omission of the front facing volume dial, and you can customize the lights from the reverse buttons. Priced at $44.99.
• Read our in-depth PowerA Advantage review
Another GameSir controller worth mentioning, the Kaleid packs in the micro-switch ABXY buttons and transports us back to the 90s with its transparent casing and lights. It didn't make the top because that sexy casing is a nightmare for pet owners, but if your home is floof-free, you may prefer this controller over the G7 SE. Priced at $49.99.
• Read our in-depth GameSir Kaleid review
“When everybody plays, we all win.” Formed in collaboration with Able Gamers and The Cerebral Palsy Foundation, the Adaptive Controller was created with disabled gamers in mind. With large, programmable buttons, numerous ports for additional accessories, and peripherals, you can tailor your gaming setup to your exact needs. Priced at $99.99.
• Read our Xbox Adaptive Controller coverage
How to choose the best Xbox controller
Choosing the perfect Xbox controller for you or your intended recipient is extremely personal, and there are few key factors to consider when looking for something that will meet your needs.
✅What is my budget?
✅Wired or wireless?
✅For standard or competitive games?
First and foremost, determine your budget. Xbox controllers can range from affordable options starting at as little as $40 up to high-end models with advanced features for $200. Standard official Xbox controllers cost around $60-$70 and will suit most gamers, but outside of that, there are fantastic third-party budget options as well as controllers for competitive gamers who don't mind paying extra for the perfect controller to give them an edge.
Secondly, consider the types of games you play most often. If you primarily enjoy single-player titles, a standard Xbox controller or something even cheaper may suit your needs just fine. They offer a comfortable, familiar layout and are available in a range of colors and designs. If you're a competitive gamer, features like customizable buttons, adjustable triggers, and enhanced grip will be important, and these may cost extra. For example, the Xbox Elite Series 2 offers these features and more.
Finally, should you choose wired or wireless? Wireless offers the convenience of untethered play and allows you to sit comfortably at a distance from your console. These usually connect by a proprietary wireless connection or USB dongle that fits into your Xbox and will require batteries or a battery pack. On the other hand, wired controllers eliminate the need for battery management, are often lighter, provide a stable connection with no input lag, and can often be a cheaper solution at the sacrifice of mobility. Many competitive gamers prefer wired. — Jennifer Young
How we test Xbox controllers
Ultimately, the right controller depends on your budget, the games you play, and overall comfort. These things vary from person to person and inspire many passionate conversations amongst our Windows Central gaming team about what the 'best' controller is for each of us.
✅We're gamers too, and we play for hours!
✅We've been testing controllers for over a decade.
✅We focus our testing on Xbox and Windows PC only.
That being said, we all test Xbox controllers to a similar set of standards. In total, we consider value, comfort, controls and features, durability, performance, battery life, compatible software, and whether or not we want to keep using the controller as time goes on. You can read more about what each of these things entails as part of our testing in the sections below:
- Value for money: A low price doesn’t always mean a good deal. We evaluate what features you get for your money, from budget options to premium controllers. Do higher-priced models justify their cost with quality materials and standout features?
- Comfort for extended use: We don't just unbox a controller and play one game. We test them over several weeks with different games to assess long-term comfort. Do our hands cramp during a 3-hour Elden Ring session? Does it handle well under sweaty, intense moments in Fortnite?
- Buttons, triggers, and sticks: Mushy buttons are a no-go. We look for responsiveness. Are the ABXY buttons snappy? Do the triggers feel satisfying? Are the sticks smooth and precise?
- Durability & build quality: We evaluate how well the controller holds up with wear and tear. Does the paint chip after repeated use? Are the triggers or sticks prone to drift? A solid build is essential for long-term gaming.
- Wireless performance & battery life: For wireless controllers, we test connection stability and battery life. Does it maintain a strong connection, and how long can you game before needing to recharge?
- Companion software: For controllers with customization software, we test how intuitive and useful it is. Does it enhance the gaming experience or feel like unnecessary bloat?
- The back of the drawer test: The ultimate deciding factor. Does this controller become part of our regular rotation, or does it get relegated to the back of the drawer, only to reappear for Player 2 in a pinch? This practical measure often reveals the true staying power of a controller. — Jennifer Young
Meet the team
Zachary Boddy has been a part of the Windows Central team for years, and has been gaming for far longer than that. They're especially fond of gaming on their Xbox Series X with a controller in hand, and has contributed multiple controller reviews and hundreds of hours of testing and analysis to Windows Central.
Jen has been part of the Windows Central team for two years and has been playing video games since the 90s. Her Xbox obsession came into full force during the Xbox 360 era, and she's put many controllers through the wringer since then, contributing numerous reviews to this site.
Jez has been writing about Xbox for almost a decade, and has tested dozens upon dozens of accessories across both console and PC during his tenure. Jez is an avid Razer Wolverine V3 enjoyer, but some of those translucent Xbox controller options are also pretty enticing.
Frequently asked questions
We get a lot of questions about Xbox controllers and gamepads in general. If while reading this, you found yourself scratching your head at some of the terminology, this section might help you.
Also, if you have any more questions about the best Xbox controllers, hit the comments, and I'll personally be sure to answer them here. — Jez Corden
How do I connect my Xbox controller to the Xbox?
To connect a wireless controller to an Xbox, if you are using a standard Xbox controller, press the X home button until it lights up. You then need to find the 'Pair' button on your Xbox. On the Xbox Series X, this is front right above the USB port. On the Xbox Series S, it is to the right of the USB port. Press this, and also press and hold the Pair button on your controller until the Xbox button flashes. Your controller is connected when the light stop flashing and stays on.
Third-party wireless controllers will likely come with a USB dongle instead, which you plug into the front of your Xbox. You'll need to check the instructions for your third-party controller, as they each have different methods. Some will plug in and play, and others may have a button on the dongle that works as a pair button.
If you have a wired controller, plug in the USB-A end of the wire to your Xbox's USB port.
How do I connect my Xbox controller to my Windows PC?
Official Xbox controllers use Bluetooth to connect. On your Windows PC, go to Settings > Devices > Bluetooth & Other Devices and turn on Bluetooth.
Next, turn on your controller by pressing the Xbox button, and enter pairing mode by pressing the small Pair button on top of the controller until the Xbox button begins to flash.
On your Windows PC, select Add Bluetooth or other device > Bluetooth. Choose Xbox Wireless Controller from the list.
How do I put my Xbox controller in pairing mode?
The Pair button is on the top of the controller near the USB port. Press this until the Xbox buttons starts flashing rapidly. This shows the controller is in pairing mode and discoverable by other devices.
Why is my Xbox controller blinking?
Your controller can blink for a few reasons.
1. The controller is in pairing mode and searching for a device.
2. The controller has lost connection to your consoles (if the light is slowly blinking). You can connect a USB cable to establish your connection.
3. The controller has low battery, it will blink to signal it needs charging or the batteries replacing.
4. The controller needs a firmware update. Go to the Xbox Accessories app on your dashboard to check if an update is available.
How do I fix Xbox controller stick drift?
There are a few things you can do to try and correct stick drift in your controller. It might not necessarily be related to wear and tear. You could first try to adjust the deadzone, which is the amount of force needed to "activate" detection of your directional inputs. On your Xbox go to Settings > Devices & Accessories > Select Controller: Choose your controller and find the Deadzone settings. Go to Adjust Deadzone and increase this to see if it improves things.
Secondly, you can try a firmware update. On your Xbox or Windows PC, open the Xbox Accessories app. Head to Update Firmware and check for any available firmware updates and install them.
Lastly, you can try a good clean. I have rescued many controllers by taking them apart and cleaning them with a cotton bud and Isopropyl alcohol. If you are brave, you can take apart your Xbox controller and clean the individual components. If you're not so brave, try some Isopropyl alcohol or compressed air around the sticks only.
What is Hall effect?
Hall effect is a technology that uses magnets and electric currents to measure the position and speed of your controller's sticks and triggers. As it uses this rather than physical contact between components, it means minimal wear and tear and more precision of movement. Currently, the official Microsoft-created Xbox controllers do not have Hall effect sticks and instead use potentiometer-based analog sticks. These rely on physical contact and, therefore, can be more prone to stick drift to competition controllers like the GameSir G7 SE.
What is the difference between membrane and microswitch?
The difference between these two button types is in construction and the feedback they provide. Membrane use a flexible membrane layer underneath the buttons you press that makes contact with a circuit board. They are softer and more cushioned, but they can wear out over time and feel less responsive. Microswitch buttons use individual mechanical switches similar to what are found in a mechanical keyboard. They feel more tactile, clicky and have a shorter actuation distance (so they measure your presses much quicker). Microswitch buttons are generally more durable than membrane buttons.
Can I get a customized Xbox Controller?
You can create a unique and customized Xbox controller via Xbox Design Lab. There you can determine colors for the front plate, back plate, buttons, and joysticks. Plus, you can get something engraved on the gamepad.
